Can A Tough, Durable Dog Toy Ever Be Indestructible?

Wouldn’t you love it if you could buy your dog a toy to last him the entire year and also keep him/her interested in it throughout? If you’re thinking “fat chance of that happening”, we don’t blame you. You’ve probably gone through the disappointment of watching a toy fresh from the store quickly torn to pieces by your dog more times than you care to remember.

Let’s Face It, Aggressive Chewing Dogs Love Destroying Toys

It’s a proven fact that most dogs, be they small, medium or large, are hardwired to destroy playthings, including the most indestructible dog toys. This is something that can be traced back to their wild ancestry. If you have the privilege of being the caretaker of such a power chewer who gets a kick out of “killing” toys, chances are there’s a pile of mangled toys lying somewhere in your house by now, courtesy of your dog’s “problem solving” abilities. Of course, this makes them all the more lovable if only the price of the toys didn’t dent your bank balance quite so much.

But it’s not just powerful dog breeds like Labs and Pit bulls that cause all the damage, small dogs like Terriers aren’t exactly known for their forgiving nature when it comes to handling toys. Whether it’s made from plush, tough durable ThermoPlastic Rubber, like TufToys, vinyl or rope, once they’ve put their minds to it, power chewers have the will to find a way of ripping to shreds any plaything they come into contact with.

Sometimes It’s Not Entirely Their Fault

We all know that teething puppies don’t need a second invitation to chew at things. At about 4 to 5 months of age, they get into this frustrating habit, not out of malice, but because they need to alleviate the discomfort they get from incoming teeth. Combine this with their natural curiosity for all things new, and they’ll promptly put anything into their mouths like any normal 2 year old, and you have a recipe which is disastrous for your shoes, furniture, and books alongside any puppy teething toys you may have.

Faced with these kinds of challenges, it’s hardly surprising that many toys don’t make it through 3 play cycles.

Are There Toys That Are Truly Indestructible?

No toy is truly indestructible. But it’s not for lack of trying on the part of dog toy manufacturers. Today there are thousands of toy products in the marketplace, all staking their claim to being the kings of indestructibility and, as a buyer, it’s easy to get confused on what to get your troublesome toy-terminator. So far, even the toughest of the toughest dog toys in the Amazon marketplace still get regular 1* reviews from disappointed dog owners who expect such toys to withstand the 235 psi of bite power such dogs as Pitbulls can produce. Compare this with some of the most powerful biters in the animal kingdom and you’ll see how such “near indestructible toys” would have some real issues faring against the Nile Crocodile

Perhaps a closer examination of these toys can help us determine how well different toys can stand up to your dog’s bullying tactics.

Chew Toys

Chewable toys are popular with dogs because they exercise his body and keep his mind occupied for hours on end while doing wonders for his oral health.  When your dog is kept busy and contented in this way, he is less likely to get into a lot of mischief, more inclined to take a nap and less likely to bite.

Chew toys come in two types to satisfy your dog’s need to gnaw at something. These are

  • Edible chew toys
  • Non–edible chews including thermoplastic rubber toys and nylon toys

Edible Chew Toys

Edible chew toys are purposely made to be destructible so as to satisfy your dog’s cravings and double up as treats. They’re made from natural materials like rawhide, chew hooves, deer antlers and bully sticks which break down into smaller pieces as they’re chewed. Some edible chew toys can have a shelf life of up to 5 years – going by the websites of some dog toy makers – so they’re fairly long-lasting.

However, concerns have been raised with regard to how safe and hygienic edible dog toys are, considering how they’re processed and treated before packaging for sale. Some have been known to cause bad reactions in a dog’s digestive system.

Non-edible chews

These are made from synthetic material like plastic, rubber, nylon or composites such as thermoplastic rubber of various strengths, which make them extra tough yet, at the same time, elastic and resilient. Because of these tensile properties chew toys made from polymers can withstand your dog’s worst punishment and have a longer lifespan than regular dog toys.

Non-edible chew toys sometimes come with additional features like tiny bristle-like projections to keep your dog’s teeth clean; these type of chew toys are not meant to be ingested, although the tiny bits of plastic which come off can be eliminated safely by your dog. These chew toys can be stuffed with treats, or coated with flavors to make for a more satisfactory chewing experience.

Thermoplastic Rubber Toys

TPR toys can be molded to be very dynamic in ways rubber and vinyl toys cannot. They can be used for interactive games such as tug-of-war where they work wonders in keeping 2 or more dogs entertained or fun and interactive fetch games when your dog has had enough of chewing them by himself.

Our Big 14″ Super Tough Dog Toy, is a perfect example of a toy that’s designed both for chewing and as an interactive toy. Because of its flexibility, both large and small aggressive chewers can exercise their jaws on it without hurting their teeth. By having an interesting shape, texture and translucent blue color, this toy keeps your dog engaged throughout, giving him the extra exercise he needs to use up all that pent-up energy. Because a dog’s visual spectrum it skewed away from the red end, they are unable to pick out red very well as opposed to blue so, for the main part, blue toys will stand out better on most carpets etc. Our Frisbee is yellow for the same reason, but this color is more suited to contrasting with the grass outdoors.

Rope Toys

dog tug ropeWhen it comes to indestructibility, the jury is still out on how rope toys perform since their toughness is largely dependent on the toy’s design. Rope toys are highly dynamic and can come in the form of knotted ropes, dolls, pull toys, or balls you can use to play fetch. The problem with the doll and ball types is that they can unravel as they’re chewed by your dog, and end up fraying around the edges. These two types are therefore best reserved for less aggressive chewers, or else you could easily end up with the same problems encountered with less durable toys.

For bigger dogs and power chewers, knotted ropes are sometimes the way to go. These can be as thick as one inch (they can take the pressure of a 90 lbs dog) and woven into a thick cord which is both tough but at the same time forgiving to your dog’s teeth. Those which are made from cotton or natural wool are especially recommended because they’re safer for your dog, and also help clean his teeth.

The one major drawback with rope toys is they tend to come loose around the edges which can choke your dog, or clog up his digestive system when bits of rope are swallowed. This is the main reason knots are made on the ropes – to make it impossible for your dog to fray the ends and potentially end up ingesting bits of rope.

Bottom line? Rope toys are great to have because you can play different kinds of games with them, but make sure you go for the right size of rope and choose one made of natural fiber.

How Do Plush Toys Compare?

You might wonder, “If plastic is so good, do I need plush?” While plush may not stand up as well to the punishment meted out by a power chewer, it’s good to remember that dogs too need some variety when it comes to the toys they play with.

Plush toys are also good for “hunting” games because they are designed to look and feel like animals. Some dogs like carrying plush toys around in their mouths while others are driven by their primitive instincts to rip them open.

Toy makers have wizened up to the destructive habits of aggressive chewers and come up with designs that are capable of surviving more destructive treatment.  Some of the toughest plush toys have an inner protective lining made of a tough synthetic material – like polyester – to reinforce the toy. The toys are also usually double stitched with heavy thread and may have the seams hidden to prevent your dog from gaining access to the toy’s innards.

The result is a toy which can “withstand over 100 pounds of tugging and pulling” according to information from some toy makers’ websites. So confident are some makers of the superiority of their indestructible plush toys that they guarantee a one-time replacement if it doesn’t meet the customer’s expectations. Generally speaking though, all but the toughest of plush toys will be easily destroyed by all but the least aggressive of chewers. Sure there are ones made of really tough synthetic material but even the toughest of these won’t be as strong as rubber and especially the strongest thermoplastic rubber composites.

Squeaky Toys

For some dogs, squeaking seems to be the sole motivation for destroying the toy. Many dog owners can attest to this queer habit where their pet hounds voraciously attack the squeaky toy, tearing it to bits and only stopping when they’ve silenced the squeaker. It’s almost as if the game is to make the squeak stop, or maybe it excites them to simply destroy the toy as quickly as possible. Certainly, you may have had this experience with your dog before- they see the objective of this toy game is to be ripped apart as soon as possible!

How do you get around this problem? Simple, put the squeaker inside a tough plastic toy! That’s what TufToys have done with their Big Tough 11″ Interactive Pet Dog Toy which also doubles up as a toy for playing fetch, as well as floating in water, making it ideal for playtime in the pool as well as dock-diving training.

Some toymakers fix multiple squeakers inside their toys just to keep things interesting. This way your dog can enjoy the toy for a longer period of time. If they’re hell-bent on making the squeaks stop, it may well be a futile exercise but fun for a while at least. Think of it as a somewhat expensive but fun little game!

Sometimes It’s Good When A Toy Is Destructible

Although in theory, we would all love it if the toys we got our pets were indestructible, the truth is it’s better for your dog if the toy comes apart when bitten really hard, especially in the case of plastic toys. Giving in to your dog’s teeth makes it less likely that your dog will hurt himself during playtime. Dogs have been known to suffer from fractured teeth which can be very painful and traumatizing, not to mention expensive when dental surgery is required to fix the problem. Imagine if you gave your dog a thick stick of polycarbonate used in police riot shields to play with and you can easily see how, although it would certainly make for a more durable toy, it would likely come at the expense of a heavy vet bill which may only be partially covered by dental insurance. So the money you might save with a truly solid indestructible dog toy is likely a false economy when you take into account vet’s bills from damaged teeth on such a toy.

Having A Variety Of Toys Helps

Of course, it goes without saying you should give your dog as much variety in toys as you can afford to stop him/her from wearing them down or getting quickly bored with one toy. Rotating the toys – taking a toy or two out of circulation and then returning them later – helps freshen up the array of toys your dog has for playtime and is also a good strategy for saving money on toys. If you allow them to figure out a quick way of destroying the toy it might be an idea to find an alternative and come back to it later. You know from personal experience dogs like to mix up their games. Don’t give them the excuse to destroy a toy just because they are bored of it.

Choose The Correct Size Toy For Your Dog

If you want the best out of your dog toy, correct sizing is really important. Dogs, like toddlers, are always susceptible to swallowing small toys, so it’s always prudent to choose a chew toy that will be big in their mouth. As a rule, any toy you get him should be larger in size than the space between your dog’s rear molars when measured across the jaws. If you’re unsure what size this might be you can always consult a dog specialist.

Don’t Dishwash, Boil, Or Microwave Regular Dog Toys

As crazy as it sounds, it can be tempting to do one of the above things (for some pet owners, at least!) to keep your dog toys squeaky clean, especially when they chew toys like bones. However, this will only subject them to harsher treatment, leading to a shorter lifespan. For chewable toys, you are advised to simply wash with warm water using a mild detergent and rinse thoroughly. Plush toys can, however, be machine washed if it says so on the label, although you should inspect the toy for wear when you’re done cleaning it. There are exceptions to this, of course, such as our 14″ Super Toy which can certainly survive the dishwasher should it become too dirty

Safety

One common thread that runs through all dog toys, regardless of type, is the need to observe safety precautions during playtime.

  • Chew toys, especially, require close supervision of your dog’s chewing activity to avoid complications such as breakage of teeth, choking or blockage of the digestive system.
  • It also isn’t advisable to choose stuffed animals for aggressive chewers as the stuffing can choke your dog. Simply go for stuffingless varieties of plush toys
  • Avoid toys with parts that are sewn on, like beads for eyes, which can cause your dog to choke if swallowed.
  • Avoid using tennis balls for playtime with really big dogs as these can sometimes present a choking hazard.
  • Constantly inspect toys for damages such as cracks, tears or fraying. If a toy is worn out you should discard it immediately. The larger and more aggressive chewing your dog, the more you should keep an eye on it to make sure it doesn’t make lighter work of the toy than you expected.

TufToys For Aggressive Chewers

When all is said and done, a toy’s ability to withstand destruction boils down to your dog’s peculiar chewing habits and the quality of the toy itself. TufToys products are tried and tested to stand up to some of the most aggressive chewing meted out by your dog without hurting their teeth. Made from long-lasting super durable ThermoPlastic Rubber (TPR), we guarantee more play cycles that your average toy which will leave your dog thoroughly entertained and exercised. Of course, we cannot and do not claim they are indestructible as this is actually not a good thing. Aggressive chewing dogs should be able to bite into toys a little bit to avoid the inevitable chips and teeth fractures that would come with a plaything that is simply too hard to bite into. Anything your dog can bite into can eventually be destroyed. The speed at which he/she will do this will obviously depend on how powerful a chewer he/she is and how intent (read hell bent) they are on destroying it. Do they see the toy as a plaything or as a challenge? This will come down to the personality of your dog and it is sometimes very difficult to ascertain the success of the toy beforehand. If they are not that interested in destroying the toy, a really tough one will last months. If they become quickly obsessed with destroying it, it might only last minutes! If our toughest toys are quickly dismissed by a power chewing rascal keen on destruction, we suspect all the toughest toys on the market will suffer the same fate. C’est la vie!

Top 150 Dog Breeds, Size, TufRank®, Names & Origin

  • The following table is ordered (in the first column) by most searched for dog breeds in Google, not popularity.
  • On the occasions where breeds have the same popular names, we have picked second choices to make them all different.
  • Click on a column to order the table in any way you like

Size

  • Small: Under 20 Lb
  • Medium: 21-50 Lb
  • Large: 51-100 Lb
  • Behemoth: 100Lb +

TufRank ®

TufRank is our highly scientific measurement of how our TufToys will stand up to your dog’s chewing power. Obviously, personality comes into this so gentle giants can also be light chewers just as teacup miniatures can also be rascally little toy destroyers. If you disagree with our TufRank, by all means leave a comment and we will look into it 🙂

  • 1 = Weak Chewer
  • 2 = Light Chewer
  • 3 = Moderate Chewer
  • 4 = Heavy Chewer
  • 5 = Power Chewer

Compare the TufRank of our TufToys with your dogs TufRank to see if they are suitable.

Search #Dog BreedSizeTufRankboygirlOrigin
#1GreyhoundLarge3BanditJunoAncient Egypt
#2Australian ShepherdMedium-Large4BaileyBrandyAustralia
#3Pitbull / Pit BullMedium-Large5WhiskeyRoxyUSA / UK
#4Shiba InuSmall4BonbonAngelJapan
#5Shih TzuSmall5BeauCupidChina
#6PomeranianSmall3TeddyCutieGermany/Poland
#7Tibetan MastiffLarge-Behemoth5BoomerMollyTibet
#8ChihuahuaSmall4StumpyTwiggyMexico
#9RottweilerLarge-Behemoth5HoochVestaGermany
#10Cane Corso / Italian MastiffLarge-Behemoth5DukeBellaItaly
#11Welsh CorgiSmall-Medium4TaffyLadyWales
#12Great DaneBehemoth3ApolloOlympasGermany
#13PugSmall3DoodlePennyChina
#14BeagleMedium3CooperDaisyUK
#15American BulldogMedium-Large5SamsonDuchessUSA
#16Border CollieMedium4CainMaggieUK/Ireland
#17English BulldogMedium5RockyMaggieEngland
#18Dachshund / WienerMedium4OscarRebaGermany
#19Siberian HuskyMedium4SergeantRebaSiberia
#20LabradoodleLarge2BootsRoxyAustralia
#21Boston TerrierSmall4ChicoSamanthaUSA
#22Bernese Mountain DogLarge-Behemoth3JabbaScarletSwitzerland
#23DobermanLarge5MaxCocoGermany
#24Great PyreneesLarge-Behemoth3MickeyHarleyFrance/Spain
#25GoldendoodleLarge4JakeLucyN. America/Australia
#26Labrador RetrieverLarge5BuddyMollyNewfoundland
#27Belgian MalinoisMedium-Large4AbelPrincessBelgium
#28Bull TerrierMedium-Large4RufusRosieEngland
#29Yorkshire Terrier / YorkieSmall3TobySophieEngland
#30German Shepherd PuppiesLarge5RomanAnnieGermany
#31Rhodesian RidgebackLarge4AaronEmpressRhodesia
#32Golden RetrieverLarge5RustyGoldieUK
#33MastiffBehemoth4KongKaigeEngland
#34Blue HeelerSmall4JinxLilyAustralia
#35Bichon FriseSmall2MidgetMinnieCanada/France/Spain/Belgium
#36Doberman PinscherLarge5RudyPepperGermany
#37English Cocker SpanielMedium4IncyQueenieEngland
#38Alaskan MalamuteLarge5PayneSammyUSA
#39BullmastiffBehemoth4MackSashaEngland
#40WeimaranerLarge5AttilaVickiGermany
#41Irish WolfhoundBehemoth3JupiterZiaBelgium/Ireland
#42SchnauzerSmall4SammyBrendaGermany
#43HavaneseSmall2PipGirlieCuba
#44German Shorthaired PointerMedium-Large4SpikeGretchenGermany
#45Australian Cattle DogMedium4ChaosHeidiAustralia
#46Shar PeiMedium3NipperMaddyChina
#47Boxer / PuppiesLarge5GaiusMercyGermany
#48Cavalier King Charles SpanielSmall2JuniorMissyUK
#49Basset HoundLarge3RileyRoxyUK/France
#50Jack Russell TerrierSmall5HarrySandyEngland
#51PoodleSmall3MurphySassyGermany/France
#52Miniature SchnauzerSmall3LuckyTwilightGermany
#53CockapooMedium3AlfieAmberUSA/UK/Germany
#54MaltipooSmall3CharlieBlossomUSA
#55Teacup YorkieSmall4InchFifiEngland
#56English MastiffBehemoth4HulkLunaEngland
#57LeonbergerBehemoth5PaxMistyGermany
#58VizslaLarge4TuckerShebaHungary/Austria
#59Miniature Pinscher / Min PinSmall3PipsqueakBonnieGermany
#60American Staffordshire TerrierMedium5RogueChloeUSA
#61PuggleMedium3ChesterCinnabunUK/China
#62Catahoula Leopard DogLarge4BismarckCyanUSA
#63MalamuteLarge-Behemoth5BusterEmmaUSA
#64Italian GreyhoundSmall3SimbaFoxyItaly
#65Rat TerrierMedium4ShadowGingerUSA
#66Caucasian ShepherdMedium4PotchiPaschaRussia
#67Portuguese Water DogMedium-Large4SparkyTashaPortugal
#68BasenjiMedium4RascalTinksD.R. Congo
#69PapillonSmall2ButtonTootsieFrance/Spain/Belgium
#70NewfoundlandBehemoth4BooneVelvetCanada/England
#71French Bulldog PuppiesMedium3EtienneAimeeFrance/England
#72Staffordshire Bull TerrierMedium5JettBabyUK
#73ChiweenieSmall2TitchBabydollMexico/Germany
#74PekingeseSmall2GusBabykinsChina
#75Wheaten TerrierMedium4DinkyKissyIreland
#76St /Saint BernardBehemoth4RugbyRainSwitzerland/France/Italy
#77Neapolitan MastiffBehemoth5LurchRinaItaly
#78CatahoulaLarge4MagnumTarynUSA
#79Golden Doodle GoldendoodleLarge5AstroAbbeyUSA/Australia
#80Scottish TerrierSmall4JockBobbiScotland
#81PomskyMedium4SamBunnyGermany/Siberia
#82Brittany SpanielMedium4RagnorCassieFrance
#83BloodhoundLarge-Behemoth5SumoCharlieFrance/UK/Belgium
#84Anatolian ShepherdLarge-Behemoth5BrinkCinderTurkey
#85Airedale TerrierMedium-Large4DonovanDarbyUK
#86Alaskan Klee KaiSmall4AshesDreamyUSA
#87Akita DogLarge-Behemoth5EdgeFloraJapan
#88Toy PoodleSmall3TinyFluffFrance
#89Chesapeake Bay RetrieverLarge5CaseyHannahUSA
#90Irish SetterLarge4JaggerHoneyIreland
#91SheltieMedium4ChaosKishiScotland
#92Brussels GriffonSmall3GooberLadybugBelgium
#93American Pitbull TerrierMedium-Large5DozerPiperUSA/UK/Ireland
#94DalmatianLarge4BobbySiouxieCroatia
#95Springer SpanielMedium-Large4MaximusBabyEngland
#96Chinese CrestedSmall3MiddyBambiChina/Mexico
#97Giant SchnauzerLarge4BrawlerCandyGermany
#98Mini Australian ShepherdSmall-Medium4JinxyCeresUSA
#99Afghan HoundLarge3TaziDianaAfghanistan/Pakistan/Iran
#100White German ShepherdLarge5WolfHelgaGermany
#101WhippetMedium 4PuddlesHiccupEngland
#102Norwegian ElkhoundMedium-Large5BrutusJasmineNorway
#103MalteseSmall2KewpieKatieMediterranean Basin
#104Old English SheepdogLarge4JoshLeahEngland
#105Pembroke Welsh CorgiSmall-Medium4PocoLovedyWales
#106Yellow/Silver/Black/Chocolate LabLarge5BuddyMollyNewfoundland
#107BernedoodleLarge4DamienRebeccaCanada
#108Border TerrierSmall4PumpkinSweetieUK
#109CavapooSmall3MiteVenusAustralia
#110ShitzuSmall3BingBongChina/Tibet
#111American Eskimo DogMedium4DanteEchoUSA/Germany
#112SchnoodleMedium-Large5BajoEllaGermany
#113Dutch ShepherdLarge5SteeleGarnetNetherlands
#114Alaskan HuskyMedium-Large5CaesarLolaUSA/Siberia
#115Belgian ShepherdLarge5BladeMayzeBelgium
#116ChinookLarge5WinstonSatinUSA
#117BoerboelBehemoth5BenSugarSouth Africa
#118Lancaster / Lancashire HeelerSmall3OliverAnnabelleEngland
#119Boykin SpanielMedium4ClevelandCinnamonUSA
#120English SetterLarge5DylanCleoEngland/Wales
#121West Highland White Terrier / WestieSmall4Itsy-BitsyCodyScotland
#122Greater Swiss Mountain DogBehemoth4FelixDixieSwitzerland
#123SchipperkeSmall3SlimEugenieBelgium
#124Standard PoodleMedium4BrunoHollyGermany
#125Redbone CoonhoundLarge5LincolnLaelUSA
#126KomondorLarge-Behemoth4ScoutMaraHungary
#127Dogue De Bordeaux / French MastiffBehemoth5JumboMignonFrance
#128Shetland SheepdogMedium5GideonPersisScotland
#129KeeshondMedium4ArchiePhoebeGermany/Netherlands
#130Tibetan TerrierMedium4SmokyPreciousTibet
#131Miniature PoodleSmall3CodyRubyFrance
#132Bull Mastiff / BullmastiffBehemoth5TexSableUK
#133Fox TerrierSmall4FestusTeenieEngland
#134AffenpinscherSmall3ShortyBeatriceGermany/France
#135Nova Scotia Duck Tolling RetrieverMedium4BiscuitBenelliCanada
#136Shih PooSmall2EzraBettyChina/Tibet
#137Black Russian TerrierLarge-Behemoth4AlexanderJezebelFormer USSR
#138CavachonSmall3SquirtNikkiEurope
#139Japanese ChinSmall2GizmoPixieJapan/China
#140SalukiMedium-Large4JesseRebaMiddle East
#141Norwich / Norfolk TerrierSmall2MunchkinRomyEngland
#142BorzoiLarge5VictorSierraRussia
#143Caucasian Ovcharka ShepherdBehemoth5MusclesWillowFormer USSR
#144Olde English BulldoggeMedium5JawsZimaUSA
#145Caucasian Mountain DogBehemoth5ChubbyZurieFormer USSR
#146PeekapooSmall3PeanutsLoisChina/Germany/France
#147Shorkie 3RogerLydiaChina/UK
#148PuliSmall2CuddlesSadieHungary

Sharing Is Caring 🙂

Can a dog toy ever be truly indestructible?

About the Author Andy

When not writing about himself in the third person, Andy spends many an hour walking his mischievous, mixed breed rescue Mr Wox, aka Soxy Woxy. A leading authority on all dog-related topics, Andy is highly respected, deeply appreciated and widely admired.

follow me on: